In Geneva, Putin Wants Respect. Biden Might Just Give Him Some.
Anton Troianovski 1 hr ago
Trump to visit U.S.-Mexico border with Texas governor
New election law now facing four separate legal challenges
Doug Mills/The New York Times President Biden described President Vladimir V. Putin as “bright” and “tough” at a news conference in Brussels on Monday. Analysts say the tone the leaders take with each other will be key to the summit’s outcome.
The Russian leader, who will meet his fifth U.S. president since taking power in 1999, has long sought the West’s respect. When Mr. Putin sits down with Mr. Biden in Geneva on Wednesday, he will have a rare opportunity to get it.
“Putin’s goal is to transition to a respectful adversarial relationship from the disrespectful one we have today,” said Vladimir Frolov, a Russian foreign affairs columnist. “That seems to be in line with Biden’s objectives for a ‘predictable and stable relationship.’”
In Moscow, wounds are still raw from the tumult of the previous administration, when hopes for a thaw in U.S.-Russia relations stemming from President Donald J. Trump’s
friendly approach were dashed by mounting sanctions and rising tensions. Now, Russian officials hear Mr. Biden’s emphasis on predictability and stability, and see a renewed opportunity for changing the course of a relationship that is plumbing its post-Cold War depths.
“We see a desire on the part of the United States to emphasize a kind of positive agenda — it’s been a long time since we’ve seen that,” said Tatiana Stanovaya, the founder of a political analysis firm, R.Politik. “This summit has huge meaning.”
There is little expectation that the Geneva summit will radically reframe the relationship between Russia and the United States. But there is hope in Russia among both supporters and critics of Mr. Putin that it will at least stop its downward spiral. Russian officials and analysts say the talks could open the door to wider negotiations on arms control and cybersecurity, and perhaps yield concrete results in the form of Moscow and Washington lifting some restrictions on each other’s diplomatic missions.
And there is the sense that Mr. Biden, for all of his talk about protecting democracy and human rights, is prepared to engage broadly with Mr. Putin despite his concerns about the treatment of the jailed opposition leader Aleksei A. Navalny
and other dissidents. To the Kremlin, recognizing Mr. Putin’s pre-eminence in Russian domestic politics is all but a prerequisite for talks.
“This is about defining a framework for the new Cold War,” said Fyodor Lukyanov, a Russian foreign policy expert who advises the Kremlin. “If Russia and the U.S. can communicate to one another that they don’t care so much about each other’s domestic situation, then everything else will be solvable.”
To critics, the fact that it was Mr. Biden who extended the invitation
for the summit to Mr. Putin in April, when Russian troops were massing on the border with Ukraine
, looks like a concession or an unjustified reward. After all, with his domestic popularity flagging and Russian parliamentary elections looming in September, the image of defending Russian interests in high-stakes talks with the American president could help Mr. Putin.
“He does not plan on signing any agreements,” an aide to Mr. Navalny, Leonid Volkov, wrote on Facebook
of Mr. Putin’s motives. “He’s coming, essentially, for one photo, literally like fans dream of a selfie with their idol.”
Key to the summit’s outcome, analysts say, will be the tone the leaders take with each other. In his interview
with NBC taped last week, Mr. Putin praised Mr. Biden as a “professional” who had spent “just about all his conscious life in politics.” That, Mr. Putin said, made Mr. Biden the opposite of Mr. Trump — a leader who, to the Kremlin’s disappointment, never delivered on the friendlier Russia policy that he had promised.
Sean Gallup/Getty Images A Swiss flag flying with the Russian and American flags in Geneva. The talks are expected to last about four to five hours.
“This is a different man,” Mr. Putin said of Mr. Biden. “I very much expect — there are pluses and minuses — that there will not be such impulsive movements on the part of the current president, that we will be able to observe certain rules of interaction and will be able to agree on things and find some points of contact.”
Mr. Biden’s roots as an advocate of diplomacy and arms control in the last decades of the Cold War strike a chord in Russia’s ruling establishment. He led a Senate delegation to the Soviet Union in 1979
to argue for nuclear weapons cuts and returned in the 1980s. Many of Mr. Putin’s backers are nostalgic for that time — when their country was an undisputed superpower, treated with respect by the United States.
Dmitri Trenin, director of the Carnegie Moscow Center, says that the Kremlin probably sees Mr. Biden as a “person of the old school, in a good sense — back when even adversaries could reach agreement on things.” Now, by contrast, Mr. Trenin said, “the American political class doesn’t just treat Putin badly. From the point of view of many observers here, they treat him insultingly badly.”
Pool photo by Maxim Blinov In an interview with NBC News in Moscow ahead of his meeting with Mr. Biden, Mr. Putin said the American president was “a different man” than his predecessor.
The prospect of the United States and Russia coming to Cold War-like terms is a long shot because of the asymmetry of today’s confrontation, he said.
“The United States is clearly more powerful,” Mr. Trenin said, “and they are not interested in rules that would limit them. Russia, on the other hand, is less powerful, if you will, but this forces it to be able to surprise the adversary.”
The Geneva talks are expected to last about four to five hours
, Dmitri S. Peskov, the Kremlin’s spokesman, said on Tuesday. They will begin with a small-group session, followed by larger-group working sessions that will include a focus on regional issues like Ukraine and Syria, said Yuri V. Ushakov, Mr. Putin’s foreign policy adviser.
Fighting climate change — long a low priority for Mr. Putin — will be high on the agenda, the Kremlin said, noting that environmental preservation was one area in which “our countries have common interests and similar approaches.”
Mr. Biden flew to Geneva ahead of the summit meeting on Tuesday, and Mr. Putin will arrive on Wednesday.
“Biden is being readied for battle and psychologically prepared, like an M.M.A. fighter,” the host Dmitri Kiselyov said on state television’s main weekly news show Sunday. “In Russia, the mood is more calm and more businesslike.”
Russian analysts are reading positive signs in some of Mr. Biden’s recent actions, despite his frequent criticism of Mr. Putin on human rights grounds. There was Mr. Biden’s decision last month to waive sanctions
against Nord Stream 2, the Russian gas pipeline to Germany; his refusal, in remarks at NATO
on Monday, to promise that Ukraine would be able to join the alliance; and his description of Mr. Putin as “bright” and “tough,” as well as “a worthy adversary.”
Even some critics of Mr. Putin inside Russia are hoping that he and Mr. Biden do find some common ground. The Kremlin’s repression of dissent has reached new heights in recent months, with Mr. Navalny jailed in January and his group outlawed as extremist
last week. But the stated reasoning behind those repressions — that Western interference in domestic affairs needed to be repelled — could become less compelling in the case of a thaw in relations with the United States.
Doug Mills/The New York Times Mr. Biden arriving in Geneva. He will be the fifth U.S. president Mr. Putin has met with since coming to power.
“If they manage to come to agreements on certain things, and there’s a sense in the Kremlin that this was a first step, then this could provide a big incentive to reduce persecution inside the country,” said Ivan I. Kurilla, an expert on Russian-American relations in St. Petersburg and a frequent Kremlin critic. “If Biden comes to Geneva and reads Putin a lecture about human rights and goes home, then I suspect Putin will do everything the other way around.”
Oleg Matsnev and Ivan Nechepurenko contributed reporting.